Two transparency-first supplement brands. Different philosophies, different strengths. Here's how to choose.
Whether you're filling gaps in a whole-foods diet, supporting a specific health goal, or building a faith-aligned supplement routine, the brand behind the bottle matters. Earthley and Just Ingredients represent two different approaches to the same goal: clean, effective supplements without the junk. Earthley is farm-to-bottle, herbalist-formulated, and deeply rooted in traditional wellness. Just Ingredients strips supplements to their essence — minimal ingredients, third-party tested, no proprietary blends. Both have earned deep loyalty. Here's how to find which serves your sanctuary better.
Option A
Earthley Herbal Supplements
Certified organic herbal tinctures, capsules, and teas. Small-batch, farm-to-bottle.
Shop Now ↗ View details →Option B
Just Ingredients Supplements
Clean-label supplements with minimal ingredients. Third-party tested, no proprietary blends.
Shop Now ↗ View details →| Feature | Earthley Herbal Supplements | Just Ingredients Supplements |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Whole herbs, organic whenever possible. Some glycerites use alcohol as preservative. | Minimal active ingredients. No proprietary blends. No artificial fillers.✓ |
| Certifications | Certified organic (many products), herbalist-formulated✓ | Third-party tested, non-GMO verified, ingredient transparent✓ |
| Price point | $$ (tinctures $14-28, teas $10-18, capsules $16-22) | $ (capsules $8-16, powders $18-28)✓ |
| Refill / Reusability | Glass bottles, some refill programs✓ | Standard bottle, some bulk options |
| Faith / Family Alignment | Herbalist-founded, mission-driven, transparent sourcing✓ | Clean-label, no proprietary blends, transparent dosing✓ |
| Where it shines | Adaptogens, elderberry, nervine herbs, herbal teas, traditional wellness✓ | Vitamin D, magnesium, zinc, protein, targeted minerals |
| Where it falls short | Some formulas use alcohol-based tinctures (not ideal for kids) | Less herbal tradition; more formulaic approach |
| Our pick | For herbal wisdom seekers and ritual-minded wellness | For science-minded supplement users on a budget |
✓ marks our preferred option in that category.
Earthley Herbal Supplements
Pros
Cons
Just Ingredients Supplements
Pros
Cons
Home Lean
Earthley — their herbal teas, elderberry syrups, and wellness tonics integrate naturally into morning and evening home rituals. The farm sourcing story aligns with intentional living values.
Body Lean
Just Ingredients edges ahead here — their minimal-ingredient philosophy means fewer allergens, fewer fillers, and more predictable outcomes for supplement-sensitive individuals.
Want Both
Both earn a place in the sanctuary. Earthley for foundational herbs, adaptogens, and traditional remedies. Just Ingredients for targeted supplements where you want to know exactly what you're taking, every capsule.
Gift Guide
Browse curated gift bundles →
Journal
Read Sanctuary Journal articles →
Shop by Intent
Explore the full catalog →
Our Verdict
This isn't really a competition — these brands serve different moments in your wellness journey. Earthley is the brand you reach for when you want to work with plant medicine traditions: elderberry for immune support, ashwagandha for stress, nervine blends for sleep. Just Ingredients is the brand you trust when you know exactly what you need in your body and you want it without any excess. A fully stocked sanctuary medicine cabinet has both — Earthley for traditional herbs and tonics, Just Ingredients for daily foundational supplements (Vitamin D, magnesium, a good multivitamin).
Can I take Earthley herbs alongside Just Ingredients supplements?
Generally yes — most herbs and mineral supplements work synergistically. If you're taking blood-thinning herbs (like ginger or turmeric from Earthley) alongside a Just Ingredients iron supplement, space them 2 hours apart. When in doubt, consult your practitioner.
Which brand is better for children?
Earthley has more child-appropriate products (glycerites instead of alcohol tinctures, elderberry syrups, kids' teas) but Just Ingredients' clean Vitamin D and simple mineral supplements are also well-tolerated by children at appropriate doses.
Do these brands use proprietary blends?
Just Ingredients is explicitly proprietary-blend-free — every ingredient and dose is on the label. Earthley is transparent but some of their multi-herb formulations do combine several herbs; they're listed on the label, but the exact ratio may not be disclosed.
Which has better third-party testing?
Just Ingredients has a more explicit third-party testing program for potency and purity on most SKUs. Earthley has organic certification as their primary quality signal but less published testing data on individual products.
Free 7-Day Guide
Get the Sanctuary Starter Guide
Seven daily practices across Faith, Health, Serenity & Intentional Living — free PDF, delivered instantly.
Free. No spam. Opt out anytime.
90 seconds
6 questions. 4 archetypes. Personalized product picks delivered to your inbox.
Discover Your Style →From the Journal
A practical guide to cleaning products that actually work — without the fragrance load, hormone disruptors, or greenwashing.
Read the article →